← All insights
Tools & Tips 20 November 2026

Write It Down Before You Know: The Decision Journal Every CEO Should Keep

Saudi business leaders and SME owners regularly make high-stakes operational choices under conditions of market uncertainty. However, executives often evaluate their past strategic choices backward based entirely on the final outcome, exposing their decision-making process to severe psychological distortion.

The Danger of "Resulting" and Hindsight Bias

When a commercial initiative succeeds, management teams tend to celebrate the choice as visionary; when it fails, the decision is immediately condemned. In decision theory, evaluating a choice strictly by its final outcome is known as "resulting"—a term popularized by decision expert Annie Duke.

Relying on resulting creates a critical executive blind spot. A flawed, reckless decision process can occasionally yield a lucky break, whereas a rigorous, highly disciplined evaluation can still encounter an unexpected bad outcome due to market variables. Without recording what was known at the moment of decision, leaders fall victim to hindsight bias—rewriting history in their minds to believe they "knew it all along".

Daniel Kahneman's Core Decision Journal Habit

To separate genuine strategic skill from raw luck, Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman recommends a straightforward operational tool: the decision journal. As highlighted by Michael Mauboussin, before finalizing any major strategic call, an executive must write down three specific elements:

  • What you expect to happen: The exact projected operational or financial result and timeline.
  • Why you expect it: The core assumptions, data points, and logic driving the choice.
  • How you feel: Your real-time confidence level, underlying hesitations, and emotional state.

Practical Saudi SME Scenario

Consider a Saudi logistics SME in Riyadh evaluating a SAR 1,500,000 expansion into a new regional distribution center. If the CEO documents their assumptions in a decision journal—citing projected client demand, fuel cost estimates, and team readiness—they establish an unvarnished baseline. If six months later fuel tariffs rise unexpectedly, reviewing the journal reveals that the decision-making process was sound, preventing the executive team from falsely blaming their initial analysis for unpredictable macro shifts.

Key Takeaways

  • Separate Outcome from Process: Do not mistake a lucky break for a sound decision, or a bad outcome for a flawed process.
  • Capture Real-Time Baseline: Document expectations, reasoning, and emotional state before knowing the final result.
  • Conduct Periodic Decision Audits: Review decision journal entries after six to twelve months to identify recurring cognitive biases.
  • Eliminate Hindsight Bias: Stop rewriting history after outcomes are revealed; rely on unvarnished pre-decision notes.

Closing Question for Your Team

When you evaluate your last major capital investment, can you prove whether its success was driven by a disciplined decision process or simply market luck?

Need a service handled?

Tell us the service you need and its tasks and we will deliver it under a service contract for a straightforward monthly fee.

Request a service Email us